Saturday, October 14, 2023

Liturgical Legos and Gospel Logic

Liturgy on the Lord’s Day, if biblically formed and properly ordered, is an experiential participation in the gospel. I have been in many worship services where every element of worship was biblical and appropriate but the arrangement of the whole was like a box of Legos, disconnected and subject to arrangement into whatever shape the pastor may have desired. This is not the way worship was structured in the Bible.


When an Israelite brought his sacrifice to the Tabernacle or Temple, there was a gospel-logic to the sequence of events. First he laid his hands on the animal, confessing his sins and identifying with his sacrifice who would die in his place. The sin offering would be followed by an ascension offering, often translated as the burnt offering because the entire animal was consumed in the fire. Here the worshiper’s consecration to God was visibly enacted. The sacrifice stood in the man of Israel’s place on that altar. It was not only the bull that was being given to God but the believer who brought him. Present your bodies as living sacrifices, holy, acceptable to God, which is your reasonable worship. Finally a peace offering would be presented. In this sacrifice, a token portion of the animal was placed on the altar, but the greater part was given to the worshiper and his family to be eaten in the presence of the Lord. The worshiper, having been cleansed and consecrated, now enjoyed communion with the God who had made peace with him.


This same pattern is seen repeatedly in the OT in corporate gatherings and covenant renewal. It is the same order found in sections of the NT: cleansing, consecration, and communion. This is how the Church ought to come before God. We confess our sins and receive his pardon. We sit under the reading and teaching of his Word as we are made holy by the God who declared us to be so by the righteousness of his Son. Then we celebrate our redemption and reconciliation. Thou preparest a table before me in the presence of mine enemies. The body of the Lamb whose blood marks the doorpost of our house is now eaten by the worshiper and his family who are hidden safely inside. We know the Destroyer will not visit this house, because it is God’s house, and he sees the blood and remembers his promise to his people.


There are many reasons to use this pattern in the Church’s weekly worship, first and foremost because it is the way we find worship structured in the Word of God. I am not claiming that all churches who do not are in explicit disobedience or unfaithful to the Lord. But this pattern is biblical, pervasive, and purposeful. It has a gospel-logic, so that no matter the subject of the sermon, no matter how well or poorly the congregation sings, no matter the clarity of the Scripture readings, the congregation will be evangelized every week, led once again through the gospel that first called them to Christ, cleansed, comforted, and confirmed in the grace that is theirs in the Lord Jesus.


In many churches, the success and value of the service depends entirely on one or two features. “How was church today?” means was the sermon interesting and powerful, was the singing loud and beautiful, were there enough Boston Creme donuts or did we have too many of the Lemon Filled ones? When worship is arranged by a biblical model of covenant renewal, these individual pieces are placed in the larger context of the Church’s experience of grace in the presence of God. No longer does the service seem to depend on the man up front or the congregation’s participation. “How was church today?” God met with us, forgave us, assured us of his love, encouraged us in our faith, and reminded us that he remembers his promise to save us. We experienced the goodness of our Lord again in the gospel. Thanks be to God. --JME

Feeding the Sheep

One of the greatest challenges in weekly preaching is remembering that you must meet your audience where they are and help them in their daily walk with Christ. The typical Reformed pastor spends a lot of time with books, reading old volumes of theology and sermons written by men who have been dead for many years, sometimes centuries. He may also spend time online or actively corresponding with other men about current theological controversies and the latest issue which has been designated the true test of orthodoxy. But when it comes time to write his weekly sermon(s), if he is a good pastor, he must remember that he was sent by Christ to shepherd a particular flock of sheep. He is not pastoring an audience on YouTube. He is not enlightening the broader presbytery by the brilliance of his exposition or saving his denomination by the power of his elocution. He is a shepherd sent to lead, feed, water, and protect particular sheep, and most of those sheep have very different priorities than their theologically attuned pastor.


Reformed churches are, rightly, critical of evangelicalish churches where the sermon is always something like Seven Ways to Have a Better Marriage or What Taylor Swift’s Eras Tour Can Teach Us About Loving Jesus. Such preaching neither edifies saints nor points the unbeliever to Jesus Christ. But Reformed churches can easily make an equal, if seemingly opposite, error by concentrating on theological minutiae or the kinds of issues that, while important, do not truly serve the needs of the sheep struggling to follow Christ in the world today. This is how we get multi-year sermon series on “the error of the Federal Vision” or multiple lessons on “the implications of the 16th century Council of Trent for assessing the Church in Rome.” Some Reformed churches are so intent on preaching justification, and so averse to anything that seems like moralizing, that they cannot bring themselves to preach the third use of the Law. I have visited churches where the preaching was solid and Christ-centered and utterly devoid of any practical application.


There is a balance. The sheep need to be warned of errors and taught how to think biblically and christianly. The saints may not always recognize why a certain issue is important or how a particular topic may be valuable to them. Faithful preaching involves laying one brick at a time, week by week, year after year, hoping and praying that the Lord will use it to build his Temple and that it will not look like the tower in a game of Jenga on round twelve.


Biblical preaching is practical, and practical preaching in Christ’s churches should always be first and foremost biblical. That is why the Reformed churches’ commitment to systematic exposition of Bible books, as a general model, is so helpful and markedly superior to the preaching in many other traditions. If the pastor is faithfully preaching his way through Bible books, the Holy Spirit will get the nutrients to the sheep that they need, whether the pastor realizes what they are or not.


Good preaching is not just teaching what to do this week or how to think about a single issue. It is forming us in the likeness of Christ. It is a means of grace used by the Spirit to chip away the remaining sinfulness and carve us more and more in the form of Jesus. It is training discernment, teaching us not only how to view one thing but learning how to look at everything through the lens of creation and covenant, Scripture and the life of our Savior, cross and future crown. Faithful preaching is an exercise in forming the christian mind, bit by bit, step by step, from the youngest child in the congregation to the oldest saint waiting on the doorstep of eternity to see Christ for the first time. --JME

Tuesday, October 10, 2023

Making Excuses for Evil

Two people groups are at war in the Middle East. The conflict is longstanding and complicated by multiple generations, and centuries, of political, social, and religious history. Grievances are claimed by both sides. Arguments are made for the righteousness of each one’s cause and for the injustice of the other.


One of these groups is an organized nation. The other is an acknowledged terrorist organization. One side allows members of the opposing ethnic and religious group to live in their society, participate in their economy, and even serve in their parliament and government positions. The other is openly committed to eradicating their opponents from the earth, not just destroying the nation, but annihilating the people as an ethnic group. One side is charged with the “sin” of occupation and colonization. The other explicitly states their commitment to genocide.


Whenever there is war, there will be collateral damage, innocent casualties, and various atrocities. Even in the most just war, prosecuted according to the strictest standards of justice and martial ethics, innocent men, women, and children will be harmed, intentionally or unintentionally. In this conflict, one side works to limit collateral damage and casualties and is committed to punishing evil and injustice within its own ranks. The other side films the atrocities its soldiers commit and publishes them on official social media platforms, celebrating the horrors which are that organization’s ordinary means of warfare, not exceptional or regrettable departures from the standard.


Hamas is deliberately, systematically, and openly making war on a civilian population. Women raped publicly and repeatedly, children decapitated, civilians taken as hostages, bodies mutilated, unarmed communities burned. How do we know these things are happening? Because Hamas films them, publishes them, celebrates them. These are not aberrant and regrettable actions set within a larger program of just war. These are war crimes, hundreds of them, terrorism and barbarity adopted as official strategy.


How did America get to the point when legislators and leaders of executive agencies would be so morally bankrupt as to offer sympathy, “context,” and patience for such evil? “Hamas’s actions are unacceptable, but we must remember the larger context,” or so we are told. “Yes, decapitating babies and serial raping and sodomizing women is bad, but Israel should suspend all military action and enter into peace negotiations.” Really? These are the same people who lecture us about blaming the victim when it comes to sexual assault. If they didn’t have double standards, they wouldn’t have any standards at all. Similarly, how did the American Church get to the point that we would tolerate such moral equivocation from its leaders? Pastors who hem around the edges of this issue demonstrate that they have no moral discernment.


You do not have to be a Zionist, neo-con, or dispensationalist to support Israel in the war with Hamas. You simply have to have a brain, a functioning moral conscience, a soul that is not entirely hellbent and darkened by self-deception and demonic lies. The State of Israel is largely secular, and even its religious population overwhelmingly rejects Jesus of Nazareth as the Messiah. But  the conduct and stated mission of Hamas is explicitly, indefensibly evil. There are no mitigating circumstances, no excuses, no room for context, nuance, or negotiation. The Arab-Israeli conflict may be complicated. The Israel-Hamas war is not.


This is not a political disagreement. It is evil incarnate. Evil must be recognized for what it is and eradicated. Every leader, soldier, and financial supporter of Hamas should be identified, hunted down, and executed. Every apologist and sympathizer for Hamas should be ashamed, publicly denounced, and removed from any position of government power and influence. This is what is right. It is what is just and necessary to protect the citizens of Israel, both Jews and Arabs. And it is what is necessary for the well-being of the Palestinian people. Their hope for peace and place in the Middle East requires the destruction of Hamas and terror organizations that practice violence in the name of freedom. –JME


See also: "Thinking Christianly about Israel"

Saturday, September 30, 2023

Running to Glory

Pagans believe history is a cycle, an alternating pattern of repetition, light and darkness, good and evil, life and death. No doubt, the Lord built cycles and patterns into creation, but history is not a cycle; it is linear; it has a trajectory. There is a beginning and an end, a purpose (telos), a goal. Suffering precedes salvation. The crown comes before the cross. But there is glory at the end of the story, and the end of this story proves to be only the end of the preface.


The cycles and patterns of repetition happen within the story. They are not the story, only rhythms in the midst of it. Birth and death. Strength and weakness. Joy and sorrow. Health and illness. Prosperity and poverty. Prayer and labor. These are the rhythms that make up our lives, the time signature for the melody. But we are not singing The Song That Never Ends. Some of the parts of this song are difficult, emotional, grievous, but we keep singing because we know the song is going somewhere.


When you find yourself on the Stairs of Cirith Ungol, it may seem like the steps will never end. When you are in the blackness of Shelob’s lair, it may seem there is no way out, no light at the end of the tunnel. When evil seems to prevail in the cave on Mt. Doom and hope fails, remember that the bitter comes before the sweet. Weeping may endure for a night, but joy comes in the morning.


We are not trapped in an endless cycle of repetition, even if our lives may feel that way at times. The sun rises and sets. Man goes to his labor and returns. Man is born, and then he dies. It seems like nothing ever changes, but Christ is the Lord of history, and the Maker’s story has a purpose. It is going somewhere. Our job is to be faithful in the middle parts.


Tomorrow the Church gathers to worship the King. We will be doing the same things we do every Sunday: singing, praying, confessing, listening, communing, and encouraging. The same thing week after week, but all of this has a purpose. Worship is teleological, just like creation and history.


When you feel trapped in the washing machine of life, lift your eyes to Jesus, behold our risen and ascended King. Give thanks to him. Praise his Name. Confess that he is the Lord of history, and that you are not. Come into the Lord’s house with joy in the morning. The rest of the world may feel as if it is running in place, but God’s saints know that we are running to glory. --JME

Friday, September 29, 2023

Christianity is Not a Team-Sport

The Lord’s Day should not be like the pep rally before the big game in which each team gathers in their home gymnasium in order to stir themselves up to fight the rival high school. The Calvinist Cougars prepare to claw the Baptist Bears. The Anglican Eagles soar high above the Lutheran Llamas. The Greek Orthodox insist that all of the other teams are ineligible to play in the league, being schismatics, the Roman Catholics claim their head coach is actually the head coach for all the other teams too, and the Divided Methodists and Lesbyterians show their ecumenical solidarity by joint displays of biodegradable Pride flags while shaking paper, climate-friendly pom-poms.


The fact is, the current state of the Lord’s Church is a mess. The Westminster Confession’s description of “more or less visible” doesn’t tell half the story. When you see what is going on in the Name of Jesus in some of these “churches,” you begin to think maybe the orcs really did descend from elves, as impossible as that seems.


I shared an elevator with a Lutheran this week. It was obvious he was making a pastoral visit, though I suspect he was not actually a pastor but a deacon, staff member, or volunteer. He saw my shirt advertising the Ezra Institute and its mission of “Informing Faith, Reforming Culture.” I saw the large silver cross around his neck. When I asked which synod he was with, he replied his church belonged to the ELCA. If the Lutheran team is the Llamas, the ELCA would be the ones on the roster with neurological disease and equine herpes. (Who knew that llamas could have neurological disease and equine herpes virus? You’re welcome.)


It occurred to me that we were two ministers riding an elevator at Children’s Hospital who have a lot in common and almost nothing in common. Both of us, presumably, have been baptized in the Name of the Triune God; we are covenantally Christian. We identify with Christian symbols and ideas. We visit hospitals in order to minister to the sick and afflicted. But the things that separate us almost seem to nullify all of the above, and I don’t mean our differences on confessional subscription, predestination, and the nature of baptismal regeneration. I’m referring to our almost certain disagreements on things like: the nature of the Triune God, the deity of Christ and his historical resurrection, the authority and sufficiency of Scripture, the historicity of Bible narratives and miracles, the exclusivity of salvation, and the necessity of a biblical ethic. The ELCA, as a general rule, doesn’t affirm any of those things. In fact, in most cases, they explicitly and proudly deny them. I think it is safe to say that I have far more in common with Martin Luther than any Lutheran who remains affiliated today with the ELCA.


The conclusion many fundamentalists and evangelicals reach is that the baptized Lutheran on the elevator is not a Christian. But, of course, he is a Christian, and that is the problem. He has been united to Christ in baptism. The fact that a husband acts like a whore does not mean that he isn’t a husband. It’s worse than that. It would be better if he were not married. But he is. That makes his whoring even more egregious. Fornication outside of marriage is a sin. Fornication inside of and against marriage is an abomination. It would be better to be an unbaptized Hindu on the day of judgment than to be a baptized Christian who insists sodomy is a moral and social good.


The Israelites in the northern kingdom were not Canaanites. They were worse. They were Israelites who acted like Canaanites. They worshiped false gods, persecuted the prophets, and broke covenant with God in every imaginable way, and in a few that Yahweh said even he had not imagined (cf. Jer. 19:5; 32:35, in fairness this was said about Judah!). Eventually the Lord divorced his covenant-breaking people, but he did not utterly forsake them. On the contrary, the promise of the prophets, the hope of the covenant God had made, was that one day Israel would be resurrected and restored, not merely to political existence, but to spiritual and covenantal life with their Lord.


What is the destiny of Christ’s Church? At the moment, she seems to have developed a multiple personality disorder and an addiction to substance abuse and self-harm. Will she continue to divide and devour herself until the Bridegroom returns? Will he come back to find a bride clothed in righteous beauty, or will he bring papers to annul the marriage before the honeymoon is over? The answer, of course, will depend on your eschatology and view of several biblical passages. My purpose is not to exegete or argue those verses here. This is a Lord’s Day devotional, not a speech in a theological debate. But to ask the question is, in some ways, to answer it. Yes, the Church will be winnowed, purified by suffering and trials. No, not every person (or denomination) visibly connected to Christ will remain until the last day. Unfruitful and diseased branches will be cut off and burned. The Lord of the vineyard will clean up his garden and make it healthy and beautiful, and that is the point here.


My sanctification is incomplete. It is easy for me to look down on the mainline Lutherans. Who wants to be a llama anyway? But there are places in my heart that are in even worse shape than their communion, because I have less excuse for my lack of holiness. I belong to a church that teaches the Bible. I know better. The only catechizing some of our mainline brethren have received is from Pastor Wolf in his rainbow colored sheepskin coat. Will the Lord abandon me because of my lingering sinfulness? No, and he will not abandon his Bride either. She needs a new diet, a gym membership, and some strong antibiotics, but she still belongs to him, and he will not allow Rev. Wormtongue and Deacon Grishnakh to have her.


There should be no pride that we are Presbyterians (or Baptists, or fill in the blank) when we gather on the Lord’s Day. If anyone boasts, let him boast in the Lord. I  am grateful for my Reformed identity and heritage, unashamedly so. I am Reformed because I believe it is the best, most faithful, most biblical expression of the religion of Christ. I am happy to discuss, debate, and defend its basic convictions and distinctions as the correct interpretation of Scripture. But there is a big difference between being Reformed because we think it is biblical and being Reformed because we think it is cooler to be a Raptor than a member of the Pentecostal Peanuts team.


The scale of identity and priority ought to be Christian, Catholic, Protestant, Reformed, and so on. It should not start with our narrowest distinctives but our broadest ones. We should see ourselves, first and foremost, in relation to Christ as members of his Body. The mainline church down the street may be so compromised as to have lost their lampstand, and Pastor Jezebel is liable to be struck down at any moment, but the baptizands in the pews are still my brothers and sisters, and some of them will be redeemed and sanctified, just as the Lord still promises to do with me and with you.


I am Reformed, paedobaptist, presbyterian, postmillennial, and theonomic, but none of those are merit badges on my robe when we gather to worship. They are not the colors of my “team,” only conclusions I have reached as I continue to study Scripture. Some of those convictions may be wrong. Even if none of those are, it is inevitable that I am in error on something else I confidently believe. But I am not saved by having all of the right answers. I am not saved because I worship in the right church in the right way as I teach and believe the right things. We are saved by Christ and by his grace alone.


When the Church assembles on the Lord’s Day, she does not meet on opposite sides of the playing field, wearing different color jerseys and rooting for sectarian success on gameday. She stands before the Maker’s throne, clothed in white. Her skin is still marred, she’s limping badly, and there are a few tumors that will have to be removed. The Lord is not finished with her yet, but one day he will be, and then we will finally be able to see how beautiful she is and always was in God’s mind. That is the Body that gathers, the Body to which we are connected. That is the Church of the risen Christ and the living God: one, holy, catholic, and apostolic, forever. --JME

Saturday, September 2, 2023

The Failure of Matriarchy

Ta'Kiya Young was shot and killed by police in the parking lot of a grocery store on August 24th. She was 21 years old, a mother with two kids at home, 6 and 3, and seven months pregnant with a third, due to be born in November. Ta'Kiya was already in the driver’s seat of her car when officers approached the vehicle and ordered her to get out. When she asked why, she was informed that store employees claimed she had stolen items. One officer stood at her window while a second positioned himself in front of the car and drew his service weapon. Ta'Kiya placed the car in drive and began to accelerate forward, driving the officer who was in front of the vehicle backwards. After shouting orders for her to stop, the officer fired one round, striking Ta'Kiya. The car subsequently rolled into the front of the store, at which time officers broke the driver’s side window to gain entry and began administering medical aid, assisted by an emergency physician who was also at the scene. Ta'Kiya was transported to the hospital where she died. 


The bodycam footage of the incident has now been released (HERE).


Ta'Kiya’s grandmother, Nadine, reported that Ta'Kiya was “family-oriented” and loving and told the local news: “It shouldn't have ever, ever, ever happened. She shouldn't be gone. It was just wrong.” Thus far there has been no word from Ta'Kiya’s husband, or father, or any mention of either man.


This is a tragic story, one at which every person who hears of it should lament. The grocery store reported to the police that Ta'Kiya had shoplifted alcohol, but who could believe that a 21 year old mother who was seven months pregnant with her third child would be drinking alcohol at that stage of pregnancy, much less stealing it? No doubt she was frightened when confronted by police, and when they ordered her to get out, Ta'Kiya made an adult decision to deescalate the situation by putting her car in gear and stepping on the accelerator. The officer who chose to stand in front of her car was obviously foolish. Didn't he know that doing so would make it difficult for her to leave the scene? Why didn't he accept the consequences of his bad decision and allowed Ta'Kiya to run him over rather than firing his gun at her?


Now Ta'Kiya is dead. So is her unborn child. The family’s lawyer said in an interview with the AP that Ta'Kiya was “murdered unjustifiably” and insisted: “She is the victim here, and we demand accountability for the loss of two precious lives — Ta'Kiya and her unborn daughter.” It is refreshing to see the unborn child counted as a human life and victim in this particular incident, even if it is in the context of human tragedy.


Where is Ta'Kiya’s husband? Where is the man (or men) who fathered her three children? Where is her father or her grandfather? Did they try to counsel Ta'Kiya? Did they counsel her when she became a teenage mother, twice? Did they talk to her about how to respond to police encounters? Have any of them spoken to Ta'Kiya’s grandmother, who is understandably distraught, and ask her not to speak to the media? Did any of them think to rebuke the family attorney, Sean Walton, or suggest that blame for this tragedy might lie elsewhere: with Ta'Kiya, with her family, and with the men who failed to guide and protect her?


It should not be surprising that this shooting is being referred to as “murder” when we see news footage every week of stores being looted without any visible resistance from employees or public safety authorities. Ta'Kiya’s family and surviving children are not the only ones who will live forever in the shadow of her shooting. So too will the two police officers and their families, so will the store employees who reported her for shoplifting, so will the doctor who tried to save her life in the parking lot and healthcare workers at the hospital who did what they could before she died. Two boys will grow up without a mother. Who will take care of them now? Will it be the same people who raised Ta'Kiya and who are characterizing her as a victim and her death as murder?


Ta'Kiya’s death is tragic on many levels, and it reinforces the fact that family structure, child rearing, and mentorship are matters of life and death. Ta'Kiya was practically a child herself, yet she was already the mother of three. She should have been painting a nursery for her daughter. Instead she was at a store gathering bottles of alcohol. The family attorney says that a witness will testify she put the bottles down inside the store before she left, but if that proves true, it only makes her attempt to flee all the more tragic and unnecessary.


Ta'Kiya did not have to get out of the car. She could have left it in park, turned off the engine, and asked the officers to let her call her dad. I wish her father had been there or her husband. I wish one of them had gone to the store in her place to get whatever alcohol they thought they needed. Ta'Kiya certainly did not need any, nor did her unborn child. I wish she had talked to the officers. I wish she had not tried to hit a police officer with her car. I wish none of the parties involved had to be in that situation or to live with the consequences that they do now.


Where was Ta'Kiya’s husband? Where was her father? Where are the men in the family willing to stand up and take responsibility for what occurred? If they are there, why are they simply standing by? Matriarchy does not strengthen human families; it weakens them. It leaves them vulnerable, exposed to dangers of all kinds, including the dangers of self-deception and self-justification about one’s own righteousness. 


Ta'Kiya did not have to die that day, but it is not the police officer’s fault that she did. He will live the rest of his life regretting that he pulled that trigger, and Ta'Kiya’s family should live the rest of their lives regretting that she pressed the accelerator of her car. Ta'Kiya’s memory is not well-served by a grandmother who makes excuses for her or a lawyer who refers to police officers as her murderers. But if there are no men to lead, to step in and say enough, to protect young women even if it must be from themselves, then this story that will continue to recur. May God have mercy upon Ta'Kiya’s family and those officers, and may America repent of the kind of matriarchy that creates such tragedy. ---JME

Friday, August 25, 2023

Absurd Clergy, Awesome Christ

You may have noticed that clergymen in 18th-19th century British novels are often absurd characters. Mr. Collins in Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice is a good example of this. 

Mr. Collins was punctual to his time, and was received with great politeness by the whole family. Mr. Bennet indeed said little; but the ladies were ready enough to talk, and Mr. Collins seemed neither in need of encouragement, nor inclined to be silent himself. He was a tall, heavy-looking young man of five-and-twenty. His air was grave and stately, and his manners were very formal. He had not been long seated before he complimented Mrs. Bennet on having so fine a family of daughters, said he had heard much of their beauty, but that, in this instance, fame had fallen short of the truth; and added, that he did not doubt her seeing them all in due time well disposed of in marriage….

They were not the only objects of Mr. Collins’s admiration. The hall, the dining-room, and all its furniture, were examined and praised; and his commendation of everything would have touched Mrs. Bennet’s heart, but for the mortifying supposition of his viewing it all as his own future property. The dinner, too, in its turn, was highly admired; and he begged to know to which of his fair cousins the excellence of its cookery was owing. But here he was set right by Mrs. Bennet, who assured him, with some asperity, that they were very well able to keep a good cook, and that her daughters had nothing to do in the kitchen. He begged pardon for having displeased her. In a softened tone she declared herself not at all offended; but he continued to apologize for about a quarter of an hour.

I do not think it is possible to really read Pride and Prejudice without grins and periodic guffaws (or more feminine giggles, if you are a lady). Mr. Bennet later compliments Mr. Collins on his talent for “flattering with delicacy,” and the ridiculous rector explained:

“They arise chiefly from what is passing at the time; and though I sometimes amuse myself with suggesting and arranging such little elegant compliments as may be adapted to ordinary occasions, I always wish to give them as unstudied an air as possible.”

Of course, Mr. Collins was an Anglican—what the Presbyterian Mattie Ross in Charles Portis’s mid-20th century American novel would derisively call a “kneeler”—but his horror at reading novels would have found approbation among the Scottish Covenanters, even if they would have never approved of him.

By tea-time… Mr. Bennet was glad to take his guest into the drawing-room again, and when tea was over, glad to invite him to read aloud to the ladies. Mr. Collins readily assented, and a book was produced; but on beholding it (for everything announced it to be from a circulating library) he started back, and, begging pardon, protested that he never read novels. Kitty stared at him, and Lydia exclaimed. Other books were produced, and after some deliberation he chose “Fordyce’s Sermons.”

Of course he did. If you fail to get the joke, look up the two volumes published by James Fordyce (another Presbyterian) in 1766. Whether you scowl or chuckle, you will know who you are in the story.


Now there is a good reason that clergymen are portrayed as somewhat ridiculous in these novels, and it is not only that some of the authors were a bit worldly in their character. It is that clergymen often have been ridiculous. Like Mr. Collins, they can sometimes be stuffy, self-important, and ingratiating. Many of them were, and are, absurd. If I had a dollar for every minister I know who is slightly effeminate, I would have a lot of dollars.


Now compare this image to the OT prophets. How does Mr. Collins measure up to Moses, Elijah, or Jeremiah? Can you imagine Amos amusing himself in his downtime by “suggesting and arranging such little elegant compliments as may be adapted to ordinary occasions”? What about the meek and gentle Jesus whose hands were strong and calloused from carpentry and who was known to flip over tables and run people out of the Temple with a whip on occasion? (We have been assured by our theological betters that the Lord would not have used the whip on any people. He only waved it around to scare them.) How would Mr. Collins and his brand of winsome, womanish, womanizers compare to the apostle Paul, his body scarred from being whipped and stoned, his eyes dim and his voice quiet but his pen sparking like fire? What might we say about Polycarp, Ignatius, Athanasius, St. Nick, St. Patrick, John Knox, and John Paton? The truth is God’s men throughout history have been men, not soft bellied milquetoasts who happen to be male.


The fact is that Christian religion in the West has been increasingly feminized for centuries. Listen to the difference between the ancient psalms and medieval hymns and the 19th century revival tunes. Can you understand how we now have contemporary “Christian” music that sounds like a Taylor Swift song? In most churches that I have served over the last 25 years, the women were the backbone of the congregation. That is no longer true where I serve now, and I hope it never will be again. Thank God for strong, faith-filled women who pray even when their men don’t, but when Israel’s strength lies in their women, something is dreadfully wrong.


Can you imagine Mr. Collins confronting King Saul, rebuking his disobedience, and then grabbing a sword and hacking King Agag into pieces? Father Mapple would have keelhauled him, Agag that is. I can’t imagine what he would do with someone like Mr. Collins. He probably would have simply walked away in disgust.


Dads, be a model of strong, masculine godliness for your children every day in your home. Take your children to church every Lord’s Day, and lead them in worship. They need to hear you sing, not timidly and not like a woman, but like a sailor, like a warrior, like a king. They need to hear you say, “Amen!”, to see you follow along in your Bible and pay attention during the sermon. They need you to ask them about it when you return home to see what they learned, because you are expecting them to learn, and they need to know that you are excited about what you are learning too. They need to see you smile and laugh, enjoying the fellowship of the saints, not scowling and dour. They need to see that the joy of the Lord is your strength.


Moms, help your children understand that Christianity is not a ladies’ social club where men are invited. This is God’s kingdom and ruled by a mighty King. Your sons are warriors, your daughters are shield maidens, and they are arrows in the hands of a warrior to be aimed, drawn, and fired downrange.


Brothers and sisters, it is an awesome privilege and duty to which we are called by our Lord. We need to bring the proper mindset. Christianity is not ridiculous, even if some of its representatives and popular portrayals may be. Laugh at the absurdity of weak sauce versions of Christianity, but do not let them determine your perspective or participation in the joyful service of the King. When Paul commanded the Corinthians to “quit like men” (play the man or be strong, 1Cor. 16:13), he did not mean pretend to pull a hamstring or get in touch with your feminine side, and he addressed that exhortation to the women too. It is for all of us, sons and daughters, to serve manfully, live joyfully, fight honorably, and die bravely. Boldly rejoice in Christ Jesus, the risen King! --JME